Defend The Children.Org

Tennessee Victims

Thomas child abuse hearing reset

Former Riverdale QB to face charges July 8; DA drops charges against wife

MURFREESBORO — A hearing for a former Riverdale High School quarterback accused of abusing his 1-month-old infant was delayed Friday until July 8, while charges against his wife have been dropped by the district attorney's office.

David A. Thomas, 24, a Mr. Football winner who led Riverdale to a state championship in 2004, and his wife, Chelsea (Kirby) Thomas, 23, a Riverdale soccer standout, were both indicted in 2010 on two counts of aggravated child abuse, accessory after the fact and aggravated assault.

An investigator at the Murfreesboro Police Department began looking into the Thomases in June 2010 after their then 1-month-old infant girl was transported to Vanderbilt Children's Hospital in Nashville suffering from multiple injuries, including fractured ribs, retinal hemorrhages, subdural hematoma and swelling of the brain.

A retinal hemorrhage is the abnormal bleeding of the blood vessels in the retina, the membrane in the back of the eye. A subdural hematoma is bleeding on the surface of the brain that can lead to difficulties with balance and walking as well as confusion.

Doctors at the Vanderbilt Children's Hospital in June 2010 told MPD investigator Tommy Roberts the infant, "with a great deal of medical certainty," had been the "victim of two episodes of severe physical abuse."

Both David and Chelsea Thomas were indicted by a Rutherford County grand jury Dec. 7, 2010. Their child was placed into the custody of his grandparents following the police department's investigation.

Since their indictment, the Rutherford County District Attorney's Office has dropped all charges against Chelsea (Kirby) Thomas via what is known as "nolle prosequi" in legal terms, according to court records.

While 16th Judicial District Attorney Bill Whitesell could not be immediately reached for comment via telephone on Friday, legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com defines "nolle prosequi" as "Latin for 'we shall no longer prosecute,' which is a declaration made to the judge by a prosecutor in a criminal case either before or during trial, meaning the case against the defendant is being dropped.

"The statement is an admission that the charges cannot be proved, that evidence has demonstrated either innocence or a fatal flaw in the prosecution's claim, or the district attorney has become convinced the accused is innocent," according to the website. "The declaration is generally made after indictment, but is not a guarantee that the person will not be indicted again."

Rutherford County Judge David Bragg had ordered two separate trials for the Thomases after Chelsea Thomas's defense attorney, William Bullock, entered a motion to sever the cases based on out-of-court statements David Thomas "may have" made about Chelsea Thomas that would be inadmissible at trial, according to court records.

Bullock also argued that David Thomas could testify on his wife's behalf that "she wasn't involved," adding that if their cases were heard as one it would be "too prejudicial."

MEMPHIS, TN (WMC-TV) - A Memphis father is charges after police said he shook his three-month-old baby so severely he had to be rushed to LeBonheur Children's Hospital.

Steven Grayson was arrested and charged with one count of aggravated child abuse after he was accused of repeatedly shaking his son.

On December 18, police were called to LeBonheur after being alerted about a possible child abuse case after the three-month-old was diagnosed with a skull fracture and bleeding on his brain.

Police said the baby had been at home inside an apartment complex off of Mill Branch near Shelby Drive.

The three-month-old was initially taken to nearby Methodist South Hospital.  Once there, paramedics rushed him to LeBonheur in critical condition.

On December 23, investigators interviewed Grayson.  According to the affidavit of complaint, he "admitted that he has shaken the three-month-old victim real hard every day since the day after Thanksgiving."

The baby was physically shaken for 22 straight days before finally being taken to the hospital.

Grayson was being held at 201 Poplar on a $100,000 bond.

Grayson has no criminal history or arrest record.  Investigators did not identify his son, so his latest condition is unknown.  According to court records, the baby is alive.

Copyright 2010 WMC-TV. All rights reserved.

Soldier Charged With Murdering Child

Man's Stepson Died From Blunt-Force Injuries

POSTED: 11:40 am CST February 19, 2009
UPDATED: 12:35 pm CST February 19, 2009

A preliminary hearing was held Thursday for a Fort Campbell soldier facing charges in connection with his child's death.

Joshua Starner, 20, listed as a specialist corporal in the Army, is accused of killing his 23-month-old stepson last week.
A detective took the stand in court Thursday and said Keegan Andrew Metz died from multiple blunt-force injuries.
Starner contends the toddler fell in the baby tub, but detectives believe he beat the child.
The abuse allegedly happened when Starner was at home alone with the boy while the child's mother was at the store.
Detectives also said they are investigating prior things related to this case, but they wouldn't elaborate.
The judge found there was enough evidence against Starner to send the case to the grand jury. He has been charged with aggravated child abuse and homicide charges.
Previous reports were that the mother left the little boy with this man for two hours and returned to find the boy unresponsive, the child was taken to the hospital where his injuries included severe anal tearing.

Father arrested for abusing 2 month old son

  • December 22nd, 2010

Murfreesboro, TN -  Justin Connors, 19, was arrested on aggravated child abuse charges Tuesday. On Dec. 15, Justin Conners’ two-month-old son was taken to Vanderbilt University Medical Center after having seizures.

A police investigation showed that the child had extensive injuries that included two subdural bleeds that were caused by abusive head trauma. The two injuries were shown to have occurred on two different occasions. The child also had at least one rib fracture that was shown to be in the healing stages at the time he was admitted to the hospital.Two days later, the detectives interviewed the child’s parents, who denied any knowledge of the injuries.

During a police interview with the father, admitted to shaking the infant on Dec. 14 “because the child was crying. He stated that he ‘lost his temper’ and was unaware he had injured the child until the child started having seizures later that evening,”

12 Year Old Locked Out Of Home For Days
His Father Faces Child Neglect Charge
August 13, 2010 5:33 PM
Karen Zatkulak

A twelve year old boy is locked out of his own home for days, according to an affidavit from Hamilton County Courts. While his father faces neglect charges, those who live nearby tell us how helpless the child was when they found him.

It was August 4th when Alice Tate called police. She, and her neighbors, had been feeding the twelve year old, and watching him. Things they say the boy's own father refused to do, as he locked his son out time and time again.

Amanda Morgan says, "I could never imagine leaving my kids by myself, letting them roam around by themselves and going days and days on end without food or shelter."

But that's what Morgan says she witnessed with a 12 year old boy who started riding bikes with her own boys. Morgan says she saw the child wandering her Red Bank neighborhood and noticed he hadn't bathed or eaten in days. She adds he was wearing a shirt and "Some khaki shorts that were filthy, nasty, nasty, no shoes."

Morgan let the boy stay with her Thursday night. He told her his father had locked him out of their house on Whitehall Road. Morgan says, "Basically no one cared, he was here all night long, all morning. How could you do that to a child?"

Down the street, Alice Tate tells us she also noticed the boy and tried to help. Tate says, "The lady in one kept him for a few nights, the guy in 5 let him stay the night, he just started going house to house until finally he just said it, my dad is gone and not coming back."

Tate says after he'd been roaming for days, she called police and made a report. It says after the boy's father locked him out, he left out to go out of town with his girlfriend.

We were there in court Friday when the boy's father John Mansfield faced a judge. With his next appearance set, he left and only told us that he thinks he will be cleared of any wrongdoing. Meanwhile those who tried to take care of the abandoned boy, say his father should have to pay. Morgan says, "I think he should go to prison at least as many years as he mistreated that boy."

The affidavit says this isn't the first time something like this has been reported. It says Mansfield has a history of neglecting his son. Mansfield is due back in court on September 10th. He faces a charge of child neglect.

In court, we learned that the little boy will be going to a group home until a decision is made.

Mother of slain girl sues DCS, father's estate

Associated Press - August 9, 2010 1:35 PM ET

DYERSBURG, Tenn. (AP) - The mother of a 15-year-old Dyersburg girl who was killed by her father after she claimed he sexually abused her is suing the state.

Jessica Readen, of Roseburg, Ore., claims the Department of Children's Services failed to protect her daughter when it moved her into the house of neighbors Todd and Susan Randolph, two doors down from her father, Christopher Milburn.

Milburn killed himself on Aug. 2 of last year, shortly after killing his daughter and Todd Randolph.

The State Gazette reports Readen's suit claims the Randolphs called a DCS caseworker's cell phone repeatedly on Aug 1 and 2 because they were concerned about Milburn's behavior, but their calls were never answered.

DCS referred a request for comment to the state attorney general's office, and that office had no comment on the suit.

Readen has also filed a $13 million lawsuit against Milburn's estate and his widow, Amber Milburn.

Pediatric Nurse, Husband Charged With Child Abuse

Posted: Jul 26, 2010 10:46 PM EDT Updated: Jul 27, 2010 11:22 AM EDT

COLUMBIA, Tenn. – A Maury County nurse and her husband have been arrested on charges of child abuse. 

A grand jury indicted Jennifer and Greg Wood on charges in connection with the abuse of their two-year-old daughter. 

The charges were filed after reports of suspicious bruises on the child. 

Jennifer Wood is a pediatric nurse at a clinic in Maury County. Greg Wood is a part-time bus driver in Maury County. 

There was no indication that Jennifer Wood harmed any of the children at the pediatric clinic. 

The couple was held on $250,000 bond.

Mt. Juliet doctor charged with abusing, killing 4-year-old daughter

Husband charged with child abuse

Staff Reports • July 12, 2010

A Wilson County grand jury has indicted a Mt. Juliet doctor on charges of first-degree murder and child abuse stemming from the death of her 4-year-old daughter. Her husband also was indicted on child abuse charges involving the girl, Kairissa Mark.



Dr. Deborah Mark, 39, and her husband, Steven Mark, 47, were arrested today.

Mt. Juliet Police officers answered a call to the home at 441 Laurel Hills Drive on July 1 and found the child unresponsive. She was taken to Summit Hospital to meet a Vanderbilt Lifeflight helicopter so she could be airlifted to Nashville. She died the next day.


Deborah Mark is charged with first-degree murder, perpetration of aggravated child abuse, aggravated child abuse and four counts of child abuse.


Steven Mark is charged with aggravated child abuse and neglect, criminal responsibility for aggravated child abuse, aggravated assault by failure to protect, four counts of child abuse and accessory after the fact.


The couple is set to appear in court July 23.

Child suffers brain injury

BY MARK BELL • MBELL@DNJ.COM • June 19, 2010

A Murfreesboro man will face a charge of aggravated child abuse in General Sessions Court next month in connection with the alleged brutal beating of a 16-month-old that left the child with traumatic brain injuries.



Rashii T. Brisbon, 32, of 2840 S. Church St., was arrested Thursday following an investigation and a subsequent interview at the Murfreesboro Police Department on Friday.

Murfreesboro Police Detective Tommy Roberts was first called to the Middle Tennessee Medical Center Emergency Room Wednesday in reference to a toddler with severe injuries. That toddler remained in a Nashville hospital Friday on life support due to the injuries, according to police.

"Upon the arrival of EMS the victim was unresponsive," Roberts reported. "They also observed bruising around the neck of the victim. Doctors at MTMC stated the baby also had bleeding on the brain."

The child was flown to Vanderbilt Children's Hospital in Nashville from MTMC via LifeFlight helicopter. Detectives Roberts and Paul Mongold went to speak with the father of the child to question him about what may have happened.

"Mr. Brisbon gave conflicting stories several times at the MTMC emergency department," Roberts reported. "Myself and DCS case worker Kevin Smith went to Vanderbilt Children's Hospital and gathered information on the injuries sustained by the victim."

The detective and case worker learned the injuries to the victim included a subdural hematoma (a form of traumatic brain injury), retinal hemorrhages (abnormal bleeding of blood vessels in the back of the eye), a damaged liver, neck injury and bruising around the neck, among other problems, according to Roberts.

"Mr. Brisbon had told the staff that the victim had fallen off a sofa and also stated the child may have choked on bread," Roberts reported. "The doctors told me the injuries sustained by the victim would not have been caused the way Mr. Brisbon stated."

Medical reports stated the "baby was a victim of non-accidental trauma caused by an adult."

Brisbon told Mongold and Roberts that he was the only adult in the home at the time the child was injured, according to a police report. Roberts interviewed Brisbon at the Murfreesboro Police Department Thursday evening.

"Based on the investigation, Mr. Brisbon was charged with aggravated child abuse," Roberts said. "Other charges are pending. Mr. Brisbon also had an outstanding warrant for desertion from the U.S. Army."

Brisbon's bond was set at $30,000 following his booking into the Rutherford County Adult Detention Center around 5 p.m. Friday. Police were unable to say Friday how or if Brisbon is related to the child.


  • Marvin Norfolk, Sr. indicted for abusing 9 year-old
  • Child was visiting over Christmas 2009
  • Norfolk's wife present during alleged abuse

Tipton County, TN 3/2/2010) A trooper with the Tennessee Highway Patrol has been indicted on a child abuse charge.

Authorities say 47-year-old Marvin Lee Norfolk, Sr. abused a nine year-old child, while his wife watched. Authorities say the child was visiting Norfolk's Brighton home for a court-approved visit over Christmas.

A jury will decide if the December 2009 incident was a spanking that went too far. The child was rushed to the hospital after his biological mother discovered bruises and welts all over his face and body.

"I think it's a personal opinion on corporal punishment. I support corporal punishment, it was used on me, but I think in all punishment it has to be in the parameters of using good common sense," says Chief Donna Turner with the Tipton County Sheriff's Office.

'I believe in discipline, but there's a fine line between discipline and violence," says neighbor Tiffany Herbert. "He should know the difference between right and wrong, what's acceptable and what's not."

Neighbors say they're shocked a trooper could find himself facing a violent charge, but it appears this is not Norfolk's first violent offense. In 2002, Covington police rushed to the THP office for a domestic assault report. Norfolk's ex-wife says she confronted him at his office where she says he grabbed her by her hair, threw her on the ground, and kicked her.

Turner says Norfolk and his wife Dawn lied to investigators after the recent child abuse incident but have been cooperative since then.

They both have been indicted on felony charges of filing a false police report. Both are free on bond and he has been placed on administrative leave with THP.

ANDERSON COUNTY, Tenn. (WVLT) A man and woman have been arrested for

 allegedly raping their three children.
 allegedly raping their three children.

The Anderson County Sheriff’s Office said a grand jury recently returned dozens of child abuse and sexual abuse indictments against Christopher William Arnold Sr., 38 of Claxton and Nancy Renee Arnold, 35 of Powell.

The pair had been under investigation by the sheriff’s office, Tennessee Department of Children’s Services and Clinch Valley Children’s Center since before the November 3rd indictments were handed down.

Both were taken into custody on Friday, November 13th.

Christopher was arrested at his home on Mehaffey road by deputies, U.S. Marshals and the Smoky Mountain Fugitive Task Force. They also discovered several marijuana plants growing in his house. He was booked on drug charges as well as 41 separate charges of child sexual offenses. That includes 12 counts for rape of a child, 12 counts of incest, 10 counts of aggravated sexual battery and 7 counts of sexual battery by an authority figure. His bond was set at $200,000.

Nancy was arrested at her home on Old Clinton Pike by U.S. Marshals and the Smoky Mountain Fugitive Task Force. She faces 11 separate charges of child sexual offenses including five counts of aggravated sexual battery, three counts rape of a child and three counts of incest. Her bond was set at $175,000.

Both will be arraigned in the Anderson County Circuit Court on November 20th.

The investigation is still considered ongoing.

Gunman, daughter among 3 dead in northwest Tenn.

DYERSBURG, Tenn. — A northwest Tennessee man accused of abusing his teenage daughter shot her to death, police said Monday, and killed a neighbor acting as her foster father before turning the gun on himself.

Christopher Milburn, 34, also shot his 15-year-old daughter's foster mother during the Sunday rampage just two houses down the street from where he lived. His daughter, whose name was not released, had been staying with the couple while the state Department of Children's Services investigated the abuse claim, Dyersburg Police Capt. Steve Isbell said.

Neighbors Tammy and Frank Hipps said Milburn was good friends with Todd Randolph, the 46-year-old foster father, and had worked for him in the past.

"They were always laughing and cutting up," Frank Hipps said. The two had even vacationed in Las Vegas together.

Hipps, 49, said he had known the two about eight years. He didn't know the details of the abuse allegations but he questioned why the girl had been placed just two houses down from her father.

"That kid shouldn't have been in that house," he said. "This might have been preventable if she had been placed with foster parents out of the community."

Neither Isbell nor child services agency spokesman Rob Johnson would elaborate on the abuse allegations other than to say the investigation began last week.

Tammy Hipps said the 15-year-old was Milburn's daughter by a previous relationship. He was married and the couple had two daughters, both younger than the teenager.

The girl's mother was living out of state, Isbell said. He was waiting for the mother to come to Dyersburg before releasing the girl's name.

Police found the teenager and Todd Randolph dead at the Randolph home. Milburn was found about a block away, dead of an apparent self-inflicted gunshot.

Charles Wootton, 71, who lives across the street from the Randolphs, said he heard five pops and thought it was firecrackers, but when he looked out the window he saw Randolph on the ground near the mailbox.

"My wife opened the door and walked out and seen the blood. That's when I called 911," he said.

Wootton said neighbors started to gather at the Randolph's house and one who is a nurse performed CPR on Randolph, who had been shot through the neck.

Randolph's wife, Susan, was sitting on the front porch with her head on her chest. Wootton said at first thought he thought she had been killed, too. "She told me who did it," Wootton said.

Susan Randolph, 45, was released Monday from a Memphis hospital.

The Randolphs have two young children who were at their grandparents' house during the shootings, Wootton said.

Wootton had moved to the neighborhood about two weeks ago, and Todd Randolph had mowed his yard several times.

"The people around here are just about the friendliest you've ever met," said Wootton. "I don't know what happened to that guy."

A prayer service for the Randolph family was planned for Monday night at their church, St. Mary's Episcopal.

Isbell said Milburn had no criminal record in Dyersburg, a city of approximately 18,000 people about 70 miles northeast of Memphis.

Tammy Hipps, 49, said Milburn worked as a counselor at the McDowell Center for Children, which helps at-risk and troubled children.

She said it was hard to believe the killings happened in their quiet suburban neighborhood where residents can walk around at all hours without fear. On Monday afternoon, Hipps put flowers and signs reading "Our prayers are with your family. God bless you. We are here for you," in the yards of both houses.

"These are two families that's been here for years and everybody knew them, and all of a sudden, this happens," Tammy Hipps said.

The shootings marked the second domestic killing rampage in Tennessee in just over two weeks.

Jacob Levi Shaffer of Fayetteville, a small town near the Alabama border about 70 miles west of Chattanooga, is accused of fatally stabbing five people and beating another to death July 18.

The victims were Shaffer's estranged wife, her teenage son, a boy who was visiting and the wife's father and brother. An acquaintance of Shaffer's was found beaten to death at a business in Huntsville, Ala

Dresden couple facing child abuse charge
A Dresden man is charged with child abuse while his wife faces an accusation of conspiracy to commit child abuse after a verbal disagreement with their daughter allegedly turned physical.
According to an affidavit of complaint, 43-year-old Jack Pflueger of Red Hill Road in Dresden, was arrested June 21 for assaulting his daughter with a belt. Michelle Pflueger was charged with criminal conspiracy to commit child abuse “as she witnessed the whipping/beating and did not stop or report the abusive act.”
Dresden Police were called to the couple’s home Sunday, June 21, for a report of child abuse. When officers arrived they found the victim with “severe bruising on her left arm, shoulder, left leg, thigh and left side of her back,” according to the affidavit.
The victim told officers she had asked her parents the day before if she could go to her boyfriend’s house and her parents told her she could not, according to the report.
She went to her bedroom and was crying when her father came in and started hitting her with a belt, the report reads.
“She started flopping around and he was just swinging the belt, and she just got hit wherever the belt landed,” Mr. Pflueger reportedly stated.
The child was placed into the custody of a relative.
The couple will reappear before Weakley County General Sessions Judge Tommy Moore at 8:30 a.m. on Wednesday, July 22.

Shelby County

Father: CURTIS LEE MORRIS, JR.

Victim(s): Isaiah Snipes (16 months)

Date of Death: Nov. 2009

Father had just obtained custody of son, 3-year-old daughter in Sept. 2009. Father charged w. 2nd-degree murder.

Warren County

Father: MITCHELL STONE

Victim(s): Kayndace (3 years), Akeelia (1 year)

Date of Death: May 2009

Custodial father, stepmother charged in deaths of two girls.

Boyfriend facing murder charge; mom named accessory

Memphis police investigators have charged the mother and boyfriend in the death of 3-year-old Amilyia Oliver on Saturday.
    

Antonio Starks, the 23-year-old boyfriend of mother Nekela Oliver, has been charged with first-degree murder in perpetration of aggravated child abuse/ neglect and one count of aggravated child abuse/ neglect.

The 29-year-old mother was charged with accessory after the fact after investigators said she lied about who may have caused her daughter's injuries.

Amilyia was unresponsive when she was taken to Delta Medical Center about 12:45 p.m. She died shortly afterward.

Officers were called to the hospital on a possible child abuse case, detaining both the mother and the boyfriend.

A report from the Shelby County Medical Examiner's Office ruled the death a homicide due to blunt force trauma to the head.

The investigation revealed Starks may have been the only adult with the child at the time of her injuries. Her mother was at work.

Oliver first told police a babysitter was responsible for the abuse, but police found no evidence to support that.

The incident occurred in their home in the 400 block of Walker that morning. A 7-year-old boy in the home has been placed in protective custody by the Department of Children's Services.

A

Father made child help as he cut up

MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) — A young girl  told police her father made her help  cut up her mother's body with an electric saw said she only was allowed to look away when the head fell to the floor.

 James Hawkins, 31, a prison parolee charged with first-degree murder in the death of Charlene Gaither, 28, a longtime companion with whom he had three children. His trial is scheduled for September and prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Police say Gaither was killed in February 2008 at the apartment she shared with Hawkins, their then 12-year-old daughter, Keyuna Thomas, and two boys, ages 9 and 11.

Keyuna, now 13, told police she saw Hawkins stab her mother in the neck with a knife and then strangle her after she threatened to call police during an argument.

The girl told police her father forced her to help as he cut up the body a day after the killing.


Authorities say Gaither died on Feb. 9, 2008, about five months after Hawkins was paroled on a 15-year prison sentence for a string of robberies. His parole was set to end in December.

Hawkins reported Gaither missing Feb. 12 and her torso was found two days later in rural Mississippi, just south of Memphis. The severed body parts were not found, and the body was identified through DNA analysis.

The girl, now in the custody of her mother's family, said her younger brothers did not witness the slaying nor see their mother's body. But, she said, she was forced to help clean up the bloody scene and drag the body to a freezer where it was stored temporarily.

"I told my dad I didn't want to do this anymore," she told police. "He says, 'You want to die, too?'"

A psychiatric exam found Hawkins competent to stand trial.

Clarksville family faces more than 70 counts of abuse

Posted: March 10, 2009 06:18 PM EDT

A Clarksville family faces more than 70 charges for allegedly torturing and abusing their two adopted daughters between March 2006 and May 2008.

Ernest Perry, 66, is charged with 20 counts of aggravated kidnapping and 10 counts of aggravated child abuse.

His wife, 52-year-old Windie Perry, faces six counts of child rape and 44 counts of aggravated child abuse or neglect.

The couple's adopted daughter, 21-year-old Elizabeth Perry, is also charged.  She faces 56 charges of abuse.

Police said the family inflicted heinous acts on the children, including torturing them with jumper cables and denying them food for several days at a time.

Some of the other allegations outlined in an indictment obtained by News 2, include: "Tying her down to a cot with ropes, handcuffs, and chains," "Forcing a broomstick down her throat," and even "Attempting to ‘cut off' her arm with an axe."

Montgomery County Assistant District Attorney Kimberly Lund says she has never seen a case like this before.

The children are under the age of 13.

Despite the charges, the Perrys say they're innocent and so does a family friend.

"I know everything about the case... and under no circumstances are they guilty," said family friend Lori Sharpe.

Sharpe is watching their home while the Perrys are in jail, and she believes the girls are lying.

She says the two girls had access to television and probably made up the scenarios based on crime shows.

"They never got spanked. [Windie Perry] did not believe in spanking her children," Sharpe said. 

A neighbor, who does not want to be identified, said the Perrys kept to themselves. "They hardly ever come outside. I never actually saw the children much either," she said.

Sharpe says these charges are all based on lies, and the parents are really the victims.

"She just wanted to give them a home," Sharpe said about Windie Perry. "She saw them on the internet and she said they looked pitiful. She said, 'My heart went out to them.'"

The Assistant District Attorney says the girls are in state custody. "To my knowledge, they're safe," Lund said.

Windie, Ernest, and Elizabeth Perry remain in the Montgomery County Jail on $200,000 bond each.

Sharpe says the Perrys have nine children. The oldest two are biological and the younger seven are all adopted.

Spring Hill Woman Accused Of Child Abuse Faces Judge

Posted: March 3, 2009 12:05 PM EST

Shelley Blair makes her first court appearance.
Shelley Blair makes her first court appearance.

FRANKLIN, Tenn. - Police have called it one of the most horrific child abuse cases they've ever seen, and Tuesday morning the woman accused faced a judge.

Shelley Blair had an arraignment in Williamson County Tuesday on eight counts of child neglect and endangerment, as well as multiple kidnapping and assault charges. 

Blair pleaded not guilty to the 15 count indictment, and her next court date was set for April 13.

Police found a malnourished 13-year-old girl and 12-year-old boy walking on the side of the road in Spring Hill in October 2008. Officers said the kids escaped from Blair's home, where police say she'd imprisoned them in a room with no food, water, light or even a bathroom.

Child abuse sentence reinstated

OAK RIDGE, Tenn. —

The conviction and sentence of an Oak Ridge man for child abuse has been reinstated, nearly 18 months after the conviction was overturned on appeal.

David Howard Hanson, 25, was sentenced to 18 years in prison in 2005 after a jury found him guilty of aggravated child abuse.

Several physicians testified during the trial that Hanson's 2-month-old daughter sustained more than 15 fractures to her legs and ribs in 2003. They concluded that abuse was the only way the baby could have sustained the fractures.

Hanson testified that he fell on the stairs while carrying the baby and a laundry basket.

An emergency room doctor testified that the injuries were not consistent with a fall but that the fractures of the legs were "buckle handle fractures," which are usually caused by twisting.

District Public Defender Tom Marshall sought a new trial for Hanson, his client, in 2006, which was denied. He then filed an appeal with the state Court  of Criminal Appeals in August 2007.

The state Court  of Criminal Appeals reversed the judgment of the trial court and dismissed the case, citing the evidence was insufficient to prove that the defendant possessed the requisite mental state for aggravated child abuse.

Only two of the three state Court  of Criminal Appeals judges concurred in the findings and the third judge concurred in part.

But on Monday, the state Supreme Court reversed the decision again.

The five Supreme Court judges all concurred on the opinion, which stated in part that the trial court provided adequate instructions and because the circumstantial evidence, as accredited by the jury, established the essential elements of the offense, the judgment of the Court of Criminal Appeals is reversed and the conviction and sentence is reinstated.

Hanson and the baby's mother lived together on West Maiden Lane at the time of the alleged abuse, and also had a newborn son together. The mother testified that she stayed with Hanson after their daughter was removed from the home and had planned to marry him.

According to the Supreme Court record, the child was given a new name by her adoptive parents and is no longer known by her birth name.

Hanson is incarcerated at the Southeastern Tennessee State Regional
Correctional Facility in Pikeville. His sentence will end in 2021.

Tripp is convicted in child molestation


A convicted child molester will be sentenced on April 7 and could spend several decades behind bars.

On Feb. 13, Patrick Tripp, 42, formerly of Kelso, was found guilty of rape of a child, aggravated child abuse, aggravated child neglect, attempted incest and sexual exploitation of a minor.

The abuse of the five-year-old boy began in 2007 and continued over several weeks when the boy was placed in Tripp’s care by his mother, investigators said.

When warrants for unrelated charges were served on Tripp by Lincoln County Sheriff’s Department deputies, he was taken into custody. The boy was also transported to the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Department at that time. It was then officials learned of the horrific abuse the child had suffered.

"There were significant injuries to the boy’s private parts," said Investigator Joyce McConnell.

Tripp forced the boy to drink hot pepper sauce, which burned the inside of his mouth. He also whipped the child with a metal studded dog collar, McConnell said.

"In this case, the system worked," said McConnell, referring to the conviction. "Twelve people held him accountable."

During the investigation, McConnell also found pornography and child pornography in Tripp’s room.

Although Tripp was staying at his ailing mother and stepfather’s home during that time, the elderly couple was not aware of the abuse.

"They had no clue he was abusing this child and cooperated fully with us," McConnell explained.

Ft Campbell Soldier Arrested

Joshua Ryan Starner, 20, who gave a 100D Ballygar St. address, was charged with aggravated child abuse. His bond was set at $1 million.

Starner is listed as an E-4 in the Army.

According to Starner's arrest warrant, on Saturday, the child's mother left the boy at home for two hours while going to the store. The boy, whose name has not been released, was in good health and doing well when the mother left.

When the mother returned from the store, the little boy was found unresponsive. The mother called 911 and the boy was taken to Vanderbilt University Children's Hospital.

Medical personnel at Vanderbilt advised that the child has severe trauma to the forehead, bad tearing of the anus, and bruises in various locations on the body, according to a news release from Clarksville Police Department. The child’s brain is swelling and his prognosis is not good. The child is in critical condition.

Knoll said the case is still being investigated and it is not known what kind of abuse the child sustained.

The lead investigator is Detective Alan Charvis, 931-648-0656, ext. 4013.

Authorities Make More Arrests in Child Abuse Case

Posted: Feb 18, 2009 09:25 PM EST

SPRING HILL, Tenn.- A new arrest in what investigators say is one of the worst child abuse cases they've ever seen.

Authorities in Williamson County arrested Anthony Talley Wednesday morning. He's charged with aggravated child neglect, especially aggravated kidnapping, aggravated kidnapping, and assault.

Investigators say Talley was Shelley Blair's accomplice. The Spring Hill woman turned herself in to police last Friday on multiple charges of child neglect, kidnapping and assault

Last October, police say they found Blair's malnourished son and daughter wandering alone on a road.  They say the kids escaped from Blair's home, where she'd imprisoned them with no food, water, bathroom, or even daylight

Rest in Peace
blackart2.jpg
Little Babies

Two Babies Killed in Memphis

 Reported by: Kevin Holmes
(10/12/08 - Memphis, TN)

Two babies killed in Memphis - within fifteen minutes of one another.  Police have taken one person into custody in the death of a 13 month-old boy.  Investigators say Jordan Holland died at Methodist South Hospital on Saturday, October 11, 2008.  The baby's mom took him to paramedics at the memphis City Fire Station Drive and Airways.  Police say he died from blunt force trauma.  They arrested the mother's boyfriend, but no charges have been filed.

Also on October 11th, officers were called to the 4200 block of Hobson.  When they arrived, paramedics were trying to revive one year-old Rosalyn Willis.  But the baby didn't make it.

All this, less than two weeks after Shelby County Mayor A.C. Wharton calls the domestic violence numbers a crisis in Shelby County.  That same crisis hit Darrel Clark's Raleigh neighborhood.  "My son came in and said, Dad the little baby next door just died."  Clark lives next door to the home where Rosalyn Willis was killed.

For Nancy Williams and the "Child Advocacy Center," it's never easy dealing with child deaths.  "These are preventable and this is a tragedy if we let children die of preventable deaths."  The number of child related deaths has more than doubled compared to this time last year.

There will be one less child shooting hoops on Darrell Clark's block in the months and years to come, and Clark says he hopes Memphis will take notice.  "It's like a wake up call to America.  What's going on with our kids.  People 60 and 70 are perceived to be dying, but in the news, you hear about young people, more about kids."

The babies who died are the eleventh and twelfth kids killed in Memphis this year due to neglect or abuse.  There is help available to families in the Mid-South at little to no cost.  The Exchange Club Family Center on Union Avenue is one of them.  For more information call the Exchange Club at (901)276-2200.

A Scott County foster father has been charged with 24 counts of statutory rape after police said they caught him having sex in a cemetery with a minor in his care.

Michael Day, 28, had been a foster parent for three years. Officials moved a 15-year-old girl out of his care, along with a second foster child.

Oneida Police said they found Bay partially clothed in a parked car in Jeffers Cemetery on Saturday, with a 15-year-old girl.

The girl reported numerous sexual encounters with Bay in multiple locations.

Bail has been set at $250,000, and he has been ordered to avoid contact with any children.

Dad accused of child abuse

Man is officer at detention facility; baby's legs broken

Authorities on Monday were holding in jail on a $100,000 bond an officer at the Mountain View Youth Development Center in Dandridge on a charge of aggravated child abuse involving his daughter.

David Malcom DeShields, 27, of Morristown was arrested about 1:30 p.m. Saturday at the detention facility.

DeShields is accused of abusing his 9-month-old daughter at his Morristown home, records show. The infant suffered broken bones in her legs.

The Morristown Police Department launched an investigation into the child's injuries after Casey DeShields, 25, took the baby to Morristown Hospital. Reports are unclear whether Casey DeShields is the infant's mother, but records state David DeShields is the father of the injured child.

Casey DeShields told officers she came home about 11 p.m. Friday after David DeShields had cared for the baby at the home the couple share and found the infant inconsolably crying. Casey DeShields gave the baby medication, but that proved ineffective. A dose of Tylenol also didn't placate the baby, records show.

The woman took the child to the hospital and noted the baby's legs were swollen, records state.

"Victim was later determined to have serious injuries, which occurred while victim was with suspect," police records state. "Mr. DeShields chose to go on to work and not come to the hospital regarding the condition of his child."

The baby had been taken Thursday to the Morristown hospital "for a broken nose allegedly caused by the suspect," according to MPD reports.

After the baby was examined at the Morristown Hospital, she was taken to East Tennessee Children's Hospital in Knoxville.

Mountain View is a detention facility for juvenile offenders and is operated by the state Department of Children's Services. Rob Johnson, spokesman for DCS, said Monday an internal affairs probe of the situation is under way.

Johnson said DeShields, who is 5 foot 11 and weighs 290 pounds, continues to be a state employee. He was hired July 23, 2007, at the juvenile center, Johnson said.

"Even if he gets out (of jail), he would not be allowed around children," Johnson said. "There is the possibility he could be placed on administrative leave with pay, pending the resolution of the charge, but that has not been resolved."

Rest in Peace
100667.jpg
Shiloh

Father arrested in death of his infant

By KATE HOWARD • Staff Writer • June 6, 2008

It appeared at first that the 10-month-old girl could have suffocated accidentally.

The autopsy told another story, and the baby's father was arrested two days later on a homicide charge.


 

Dwaniko Sudberry, 23, who has a history of child abuse, is being held without bail in the death of Shiloh Sneed.

The baby's mother called 911 on Tuesday after returning about noon to Sudberry's home on Ashmont Court and finding her baby wasn't breathing, Metro police said.

Sudberry, the baby's father, was keeping the child while the mother was at work. CPR by detectives and EMTs wasn't successful and the baby was pronounced dead at Southern Hills Medical Center.

Police initially thought the baby might have suffocated on bedding.

An autopsy showed internal injuries including broken ribs, internal bleeding near her brain and a spleen laceration.

Sudberry was booked into jail Thursday afternoon.

He pleaded guilty last August to a charge of child abuse involving a child under 6 after striking his then-girlfriend's 3-year-old daughter with a shoe.

According to court documents, the girl told her mother that bruises on her buttocks and legs were from falling off her bike. But later that day, she told her grandmother that Sudberry took her out to the car and struck her repeatedly with a shoe when she wouldn't go to sleep.

He also made her promise not to tell her mom, according to a police report.

Sudberry also pleaded guilty to statutory rape involving a 17-year-old girl who became pregnant.

The child abuse plea brought a three-year sentence to be served on probation. He was sentenced to 11½ months in jail after the statutory rape plea; all but 60 days were suspended.

Other charges on his record include driving on a suspended license and evading arrest.

Contact Kate Howard at 726-8968 or kahoward@tennessean.com

Surveillance tape leads to tips on abuser
Jan 07, 2008
A convenience store surveillance tape has led to the arrest of a 27-year old for brutally assaulting his girlfriend's 19-month old son. Detroit police released part of the tape, showing the suspect kicking and stepping on the toddler, then slamming his head into a glass cooler door. "When the video aired, our department was flooded with tips," says James Tate, a police spokesman. The Detroit Free Press reports that Joseph Gray has admitted he is the person in the video. Gray has been charged with second- and third-degree child abuse.

Man Charged in Kids' Dog-Collar Shock, Rape

Tenn. Man Allegedly Used Electric Dog Collar on Children as Stepmother Watched

 
Tennessee husband and wife Wayne and Rebecca Burkhart were arrested in September. Wayne Burkhart faces two counts of aggravated child assault and two counts of rape. Rebecca Burkhart was charged with aggravated child neglect and failing to report child abuse. (Claiborne County Sheriff's Office )
 

Wayne Burkhart Jr., 38, and his wife, Rebecca, 35, were in court yesterday as Claiborne County Judge Robert Estep ruled that the case should go before a grand jury.

"We're pleased with yesterday's results, and we feel the judge's decision was consistent with the evidence," Claiborne County Assistant District Attorney Jared Effler told ABC News.

Burkhart's 17-year-old daughter told authorities in a Sept. 10 interview that she had been sexually and physically abused by her father, according to the complaint affidavit. "Among other things, her father [the defendant] uses dog collars equipped with electric shock to train his hunting dogs, and that he uses the collar on her to shock her and her 19-year-old sister," the affidavit reads.

The teen told authorities her father used the shock collar on her Sept. 9 "because he was mad at her for going out with a boy."

The teen also said that her mother had witnessed this and that her father typically put the collar around her midcalf to shock her. The girl's siblings, 15, 11 and 13, corroborated the account, according to the court documents.

Both teens showed investigators bruises consistent with an electric dog collar and the girl also said that her father held a shotgun to her head and said that if she "ever told anyone, he would kill himself, her and anyone who tried to remove her from his home," the affidavit reads.

Burkhart's children also said that their stepmother, Rebecca Burkhart, had been present when the dog collar was used. "At none of these times," the affidavit reads, "did [Rebecca Burkhart] attempt to call law enforcement or seek medical treatment for her stepdaughter

 
 
Wednesday, 02/01/06 Grand jury to hear injured infant case By Patricia Lynch Kimbro Staff Writer
 
The parents of an infant whose right leg was broken were bound over Friday to the February term of the Dickson County grand jury. Anthony Barker, 32, of Vanleer is charged with aggravated child abuse and remains in the Dickson County Jail in lieu of $250,000 bond. His wife, Summar Barker, 22, is charged with accessory after the fact and is free on a $2,000 bond.
 
 Anthony Barker had previously told investigators he was changing his son’s diaper sometime between 10 p.m. Jan. 2 and 2 a.m. Jan. 3 when he grabbed and twisted the then 3-week-old baby’s right leg, causing a break. Dickson County authorities were notified about the incident Jan. 4 after officials at Vanderbilt Children’s Hospital called the Department of Children’s Services to investigate the case.
 
Testimony showed Anthony Barker spent a couple of years in jail on another child abuse charge a few years ago in which the 7-month-old infant of a former girlfriend was injured while in his care. Deborah Stacy of Waverly is the mother of that child. Stacy was in court Friday, but did not testify. After the court proceedings she told The Dickson Herald that she was surprised when she heard about the latest incident involving Anthony Barker. “I honestly thought he would have changed. I thought he had changed,” Stacy said. Stacy said her son, who is now five years old, is autistic and blind in his right eye. She said the doctors have been unable to determine whether it was due to the shaking at the hands of Anthony Barker. “My son had three subdural hematomas to his brain and a compressed disc and a detached retina in his right eye. He’s been diagnosed as developmentally disabled and autistic. But they (the doctors) can’t verify if it was directly related to the incident of shaking. But my son had no prior symptoms before that happened,” Stacy said. The incident occurred in October 2000, she said. Barker served two years in jail and was in the community corrections program when the latest incident occurred.
 
When initially questioned by investigators on the latest incident, Anthony Barker, according to Dickson County Sheriff’s Detective John Patterson, did not immediately admit he had done anything to his child. He also did not mention the prior incident involving Stacy’s child until later, testimony revealed. But later at the sheriff’s office during interrogation, Anthony Barker admitted that he knew Patterson due to his prior time in jail, according to testimony.

Rest In Peace
angelpicturepretty4th.jpg
Anthony

In Nashville, Tenn. Aja Westbrooks, 21, and her live-in boyfriend, Larry Cook II, 19, were charged with one count of aggravated child abuse and one count of aggravated child neglect for the death of  her 31-month-old son, Anthony Westbrooks.

Anthony’s injuries included brain damage and bruising. . Cook claims that Anthony fell down the stairs, and he tried to revive the little boy when he stopped breathing. However, doctors and the police felt this was that this was a case of child abuse.

 In 2004 when he was seven months old, Anthony was removed from his mother's r custody when it was discovered he had a broken bone in his leg. However, Westbrooks petitioned the court and  to regained custody of Anthony in May 2005.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Finally this little boy is safe, his abusive  father has given up his parental rights.
The 4-year-old boy went in for a checkup and a pediatrician thought something was wrong.

The pediatrician said the boy may have been exposed to inappropriate sexual behavior while on weekend visits with his father.

The pediatrician referred the case to a therapist who agreed and referred the case to a psychologist who also agreed.

A police investigation began and police agreed that the boy appeared to be sexually abused when visiting his father.

Butler said her family asked Wilson County Circuit Court Judge Clara Byrd to cease visitations and order the father to take a lie detector test and undergo psychosexual evaluation.

Butler said Byrd wanted to talk to the child. Butler said Byrd conducted a 10 minute interview with the child in her chambers.

“When she came out, I think her words were, ‘OK, call off the dogs, call off the psychologists, call off the therapists. You attorneys call off your CVSA testing for tomorrow because this didn’t happen,’” Butler said.

After the meeting, Byrd decided to continue the father's visitation and discredit the Department of Children’s Services investigation.

“I left there with a sense of ‘What is she thinking? Why would you not try and protect this child?’” Butler said.

That was January of 2005. In August of 2005, the Butlers were back in court for a custody hearing.

The Butlers produced two experts that said the child appeared to have been sexually abused.

The father didn’t have any expert witnesses, and Byrd gave the father full custody of the child.

Butler said she was helpless and was just trying to protect the child, but that there was no way to stop the court order.

“The bottom line was, this mother had never done anything except try to protect her child at the advice of professionals who gave her advice,” she said. “It was almost worse than if that child had died. It’s just like a piece of your heart is gone. … It’s like you get up every day and you just can’t go on.”

Attorney Cyndi Cheatham said she couldn't believe that it appeared the judge had based everything on a short interview with a 4-year-old.

“Every time, you know, we would say, ‘Well, this has gone so far field of what you would think would happen.’ It would get worse,” she said.

Butler's retired husband of 46 years went back to work to pay the legal costs of fighting for the boy.

“We were determined if it took every penny we had that you keep fighting. You keep fighting for your family,” Butler said.

The couple said their retirement fund was gone and that they needed money to appeal the decision.

“What’s money? You can’t put a price on a child’s life. You know, had we not done this, if we had gone out on a cruise or gone somewhere else, could I have enjoyed it? No,” Butler said.

The Tennessee Court of Appeals saw things Butlers' way and reversed every aspect of Byrd's decision and ordered the child back to her mother and vacating her decision entirely.

The court of appeals said what the Butlers said. The ruling stated that Byrd’s rulings were "based almost entirely on the trial court's interview of the child" and "the evidence simply does not support the findings by the trial court."

The case moved to Davidson County where the new judge reversed the previous decisions.

The judge awarded custody of the child to Butler and ordered psychosexual evaluation of the father and a lie-detector test.

After two days, the father gave up his parental rights.

“Two days after we were in court, we heard from the father’s attorney. He wanted to voluntarily surrender his parental rights, and that’s been done,” Butler said. She said they had not heard from the father since.

Byrd did not return any phone calls for an interview.
 
 
Court shoots down Byrd’s rulings

By EVAN McMORRIS-SANTORO

A 2006 legal error by Circuit Court Judge Clara Byrd led to her receiving one of the strictest findings that can be issued by the Court of Appeals in Tennessee.

The case, which has received recent media attention, involved the appellate court’s ruling that Byrd, an elected Wilson County judge, improperly left a child in the custody of his father, a suspected child abuser.

The case was brought to light by the boy’s grandmother, Wilson County resident Brenda Butler.

According to court documents, Byrd ignored a Department of Children’s Services finding of abuse as well as a police investigation of the father’s behavior, preferring to grant the father visitation rights after a 10-minute interview with the child she conducted in her chambers.

The state Court of Appeals reversed Byrd’s ruling entirely on Aug. 30, 2006, saying that her finding was not supported by the evidence presented at trial. The appeals court ordered Byrd to immediately return the boy to the custody of his mother and that the case be transferred to Davidson County’s Circuit Court.

Following the release of the appellate court’s ruling, the mother filed a motion in Byrd’s court requesting she be granted immediate custody of the child and that the case be transferred to Davidson County.

However, instead of complying with the higher court’s ruling, Byrd left the boy in his father’s care and held a hearing on Friday, Sept. 22, 2006.

On Monday, Sept. 25, the child’s mother filed an application with the Court of Appeals requesting that the court enter an expedited order granting her immediate custody of the child.

“Following the filing of the mother’s application with this court, the trial court [Byrd] entered an order holding that it has no jurisdiction over any matters whatsoever and transferring the case to the Circuit Court for Davidson County,” states the appellate court’s ruling.

“The mandate of this court is clear,” the ruling filed on Sept. 26 in the Clerk of Courts continues. “It requires the trial court [Byrd] to act immediately (1) to restore custody of the child to the mother ... and (2) to transfer the case to the Circuit Court of Davidson County.

“The trial court has departed from the accepted and usual course of judicial proceedings by failing to restore custody of the child to the mother immediately.”

Byrd’s failure to follow the higher court’s ruling led the Court of Appeals to issue one of its strictest findings, a Rule 10 order, so-called because of the section of the appellate court rules where it’s found.

A Rule 10 – also known as an “extraordinary appeal” – is issued only when the appeals court finds a lower court has “departed from the usual and accepted course of judicial proceedings.” In the case of Butler’s grandson, the Court of Appeals was far more direct than that, suggesting that Byrd ignored its orders.

“The trial court has refused to enter an order consistent with the mandate of this court,” the Court of Appeals ruling reads in part.

Not Byrd’s first
involvement with
Court of Appeals

This latest court case is not the first time a higher court has disagreed with rulings issued by Byrd.

More than two-thirds of the rulings appealed from Byrd’s court over the last four years have either been altered by the higher court, according to an independent review of the appealed cases conducted for The Lebanon Democrat.

The review was conducted for the paper by a Nashville attorney. The attorney’s review found Byrd has had 20 of her rulings heard in the state Court of Appeals over the last four years. One of those cases was “moot,” meaning that Byrd’s ruling was not affirmed or reversed. Of the remaining 19 rulings, 65 percent were either reversed entirely, reversed in part or modified by the higher court.

According to legal scholars, a reversal rate that high makes Byrd unique among her colleagues on the bench.

As happens with many state judges, a broad spectrum of different case types have been appealed to a higher court after Byrd has ruled on them. But legal scholars say that unlike most judges, Byrd’s rulings are more often than not altered or modified by the Court of Appeals of Tennessee that reviews them.

Either party in a given court case can appeal a judge’s ruling to a higher court. Generally, appellate judges will modify or reverse a case from a lower court because new evidence is introduced or the lower court judge misinterpreted the law or otherwise acted improperly.

“Appeals courts are more interested in ruling based on matters of law versus new evidence,” explained Stephanie Linquist, an associate professor at Vanderbilt Law School and an expert on appellate law. The professor said that at the state court level, the number of cases reversed on appeal normally averages around 30 percent, half of Byrd’s number.

“Appellate courts don’t get to see all the witnesses testify like trial courts do, so they’re more deferential to factual findings,” Linquist said. “Given that, if she’s being reversed at such a high rate, it’s probably because she’s making consistent or frequent legal errors.”
Linquist said that an appeals record like Byrd’s could be reason for concern.

“Overall, rates that high are just not a good thing for the legal system,” she said.

The Lebanon Democrat placed multiple calls to Byrd for comment and none were returned.

amicus brief on the case

I am so thankful that your website and others like it is here. It is such a help to those who are going through the difficult times of hurt and pain associated with the loss of a child. I am one of the persons in one of your stories, and I hope my story gives encouragement to others that sometimes there is justice. By the grace of God we have our little one back. God bless you for what you are doing.
Brenda Butler (grandmother)

  

Goodrum, Sawyer Receive Sentence in Child Rape Case

  
  This is placed here because of the 
terrible injustice.  This baby was only one day old and in the hospital when  her father, raped her.  He served one year and than has 9 years probation.  He said he will fight for visitation.  Because of the age of this child, there is no previous child abuse charges files and it is unknown if any were filed for the one year old sibling.    The mother plead guilty for not protecting.

Jonathan Wayne Goodrum is escorted into Carroll County Circuit Court by Chief Deputy Terry Dickey.

 
By Joel Washburn
washburn@mckenziebanner.com

Listen to an excerpt of the trial

Sound off on the HenryCountian.com Blog

HUNTINGDON (March 8, 2007) Jonathan Wayne Goodrum and ex-fiancée Kristina Louise Sawyer both pled guilty in the March 24, 2006 rape case of their one-day old infant. Goodrum, 20, and Sawyer, age 19, both of McKenzie, entered pleas in Carroll County Circuit Court.

Last year, the case made national attention through the media and Internet blogs. Goodrum was originally charged with rape of a child under age 13 and she was charged with rape of a child. The charge of rape of a child has a sentencing range of 15 to 60 years and up to $50,000 fine.

Circuit Judge Donald Parish heard the two cases Thursday.


Kristina Louise Sawyer with defense counsel Steve West.

In an agreement, Goodrum pled guilty to attempted rape of a child. He received a sentence of 10 years imprisonment, which includes one year in continuous incarceration and the remaining nine year on probation in the community corrections program. He must also register as a lifetime sexual offender and is required to obtain counseling and therapy at his own expense and must not have contact with the victim unless authorized by the court. Goodrum has already served 11 months of the mandated one-year continuous incarceration. He will be released early next month or sooner if he receives credit for good behavior, officials said.

Goodrum, wearing a striped jail uniform and shackles was escorted in by Chief Deputy Terry Dickey. He proceeded to the defendant’s table to sit next to defense counsel Ben Dempsey. Judge Donald Parish asked Goodrum to stand and speak into the microphone and asked Deputy Dickey to remove Goodrum’s hand restraints.

Parish asked Goodrum a litany of questions concerning the understanding of his rights to a trial, noting that if he pleaded guilty he would not have the right to appeal and that punishment for any future convictions could carry an enhanced sentence.

The plea agreement was put forward because the prosecution did not believe it would have a lock-tight case. District Attorney Hansel McCadams said a Jackson doctor, who specializes in sex abuse cases, could not rule that the injury to the child was caused by a criminal act and could have been caused by some other procedure, even the improper use of a thermometer. There was no eyewitness to the reported crime and a video and medical records did not conclude Goodrum’s guilt, said McCadams. The timeline of events was also problematic for the prosecution, which could have resulted in a “not guilty” verdict if it had gone to trial.

The case was scheduled for 9:00 a.m. but actually occurred closer to 9:30 a.m. McCadams said the parties were trying to agree on a plea during that time.

“We felt we did not want to outright lose it,” said McCadams. “That’s why we offered the deal.” As for why Goodrum pled guilty, McCadams said the plea was the option that got him out of jail quickest. The family wanted him under some type of conviction.

Sawyer, the mother of the baby, pled guilty to violation of duty to report child abuse. She was sentenced to 11 months, 29 days, which includes 60 days of continuous confinement with the remainder in supervised probation. She has already served 64 days in the Carroll County Jail. She will be credited the extra four days confinement against the supervised probation sentence. Her contact with the infant child will be restricted as ordered by the Department of Children’s Services.

In the original report, McKenzie Police Lieutenant Tim Nanney reported Goodrum allegedly had unlawful sexual contact with his daughter by penetrating her with an unknown object. The child was in McKenzie Regional Hospital at the time of the incident and tears in the child’s body were discovered by nurses during an assessment of the infant. The child remained hospitalized for several days and has been placed in the custody of the mother’s sister. Sawyer previously had another child removed from her custody, according to authorities.

Sawyer had previously made a deal with the state to testify against Goodrum if it had gone to jury trial.

Click for Walking in Memphis

Tennessee Laws

Tennessee Protective Parent Reform Act - Passed May 10, 2004.
 Click here for Text of the Act
.

Click here for Article about Tennessee passing the Protective Parent Reform Act.

Copywrite and Fair Use information

Who to Contact in Congress

coa.jpg

This site  The Web 

Per US laws, anyone accused of or arrested for a crime is innocent by law until which time he or she is convicted in a court of law. 

Please email admin at defend_children@yahoo.com if you wish to join or to correspond with us.  Also if you would like to give suggestions or ask questions please email usat defendthechildren@live.com Thank you

Please note  We are not affiliated with and we do not endorse www.defendchildren.com
We are
www.DefendTHEChildren.com  and www.DefendTheChildren.org.